Bathtub Liners vs. a Bathtub Refinishing: What’s Your Best Option?

Replacing a bathtub can be a messy, tedious, and expensive job. The old tub might need to be cut up to be removed, or walls may need to be cut open to make space to remove the tub. Yet you don’t want to live with an aging tub for any longer.

Fortunately, you have a few options for giving your tub a new look without having to go through the trouble of replacing the tub. You can either refinish the tub in Arizona, which involves patching and repainting the tub, or you can put in a new bathtub liner, which is placed directly on top of the old bathtub. Here’s a quick breakdown of how the two options compare to help you make the best choice for your home:


One of the biggest drawbacks to replacing an old tub is the mess that it makes. There will be dust and debris everywhere from cutting the tub, and you could have drywall and insulation debris, as well, if the contractors have to cut through the wall.

Both installing a new tub liner and refinishing a tub will create some mess also, but it will be far less than replacing the tub. The liner will be ordered to fit your tub, so it shouldn’t need to be cut. It may need a bit of sanding or polishing, but the mess will be minimal. Refinishing a tub will require a lot of sanding and painting, so it create more mess than installing a liner. However, an Arizona professional tub refinisher will minimize the mess for either option.


Bathtub liners are very durable since they provide an additional layer made of the same material as the tub in most cases. They should last as long as the original tub did.

Bathtub refinishing involves patching cracks and repainting the tub. So long as the Arizona’s tub refinishing is performed by an experienced professional, it should last many more years to come.


Bathtub refinishing will cost less than installing a bathtub liner, and it will cost far less than replacing your bathtub. The exact cost will vary depending on the size, type, and condition of your tub, as well as your location and the professional you choose for the job. However, you can expect to spend a few hundred dollars to refinish a bathtub, while you can expect to spend closer to $1,500-$2,000 for installing a new bathtub liner.


Refinishing around Arizona typically produces better results than installing a new bathtub liner because it maintains the exact contours and details of your tub. A liner may not have the same design as your original tub, and it will cover up some of those details you may like.

If you have a tub that is very damaged, a liner may produce a better appearance. The liner will cover up dents and other imperfections that refinishing can’t disguise.

Ultimately, whether bathtub refinishing or a new bathtub liner will be better for your tub will depend upon the condition of your tub and what you want it to look like when it’s done. In most cases, simple bathtub refinishing can produce transformational results in the quickest amount of time and for the least amount of money. Refinishing can’t fix severe damage, so you’ll need to consult with an experienced bathtub refinisher to find out what the best options will be for your tub and your goals for it. You don’t have to resign yourself to an expensive and messy bathtub replacement.

Todd’s Bathtubs can help you if you have an old or damaged tub that you want to restore. We specialize in repairing and restoring fiberglass, porcelain, acrylic, and cultured marble tubs, showers and bathroom sinks. We can make your bathroom look like new again with basic repairs and refinishing. You can also refinish your tub if you are looking for a new look but don’t want to invest in a remodel. We offer bathtub chip repair, crack repair, and refinishing in Mesa and the surrounding areas. Call us today to learn more about our bathtub refinishing services or to schedule an estimate for your job. You won’t believe the results that we can achieve.

Published By:

Todd’s Porcelain & Fiberglass Repair

1829 S Horne #14, Mesa, AZ 85204
Business Hours: